Stone Deaf Forever: Discourses of Loudness
Pages 29 to 49
Cite this article
- PERCIVAL, J. Mark,
- Percival, J. Mark.
- Percival, J.-M.
https://doi.org/10.4000/volume.4473
Cite this article
- Percival, J.-M.
- Percival, J. Mark.
- PERCIVAL, J. Mark,
https://doi.org/10.4000/volume.4473
Notes
-
[1]
Bosma, Hanna (2005), “Different Noises in Electroacoustic Music”, ASCA Conference Sonic Interventions: Pushing the Boundaries of Cultural Analysis, Reader for Panel 2: The Sonic in the “Silent” Arts and Bring in the Noise, 2005, coordinator: Sylvia Mieszkowski: 18–23, as discussed by Cloonan & Johnson, 2008: 21.
-
[2]
Played by real-life director of This Is Spinal Tap, Rob Reiner.
-
[3]
Likely to be the standard 100w version of the amplifier, though the 50w version of this generation of amplifier looked identical from the front. The late Jim Marshall (died, 2012), founder of the eponymous British amplifier company was often referred to as “The Father of Loud” (Maloof, 2004).
-
[4]
Transcribed from the short promotional film, Nigel Tufnel—“20” (c.1990). Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iwuZePiQHLI.
-
[5]
More surprising perhaps is the 1993 Meat Loaf track that uses Blackmore's joking request as a song title. Lyrically this song has nothing to do with live performance volume—the chorus features a protagonist who claims to like his music the way he likes his life, “Everything Louder Than Everything Else” (from Bat Out Of Hell 2: Back Into Hell, 1993).
-
[6]
Transcribed from Episode 5 of the 1981 BBC Television adaptation of The Hitchhiker's Guide To The Galaxy, first broadcast 02 February 1981 (Hitchhiker Wiki, 2013).
- [7]
-
[8]
1973 marked the beginning of Status Quo's UK commercial breakthrough with the albums Piledriver (1972) and Hello! (1973).
-
[9]
As noted by, amongst others, Waksman (2009: 326).
-
[10]
The leaning of volume-up electric guitars against loud amplifiers and walking off stage is probably a micro-social act of rock performativity deserving of its own article, but here at least it is an explicit example of the role of the front-of-house PA system. There was probably nothing stopping the sound engineer from dropping the levels on the guitar amp microphone to ease the pain of uncontrolled feedback, and yet he apparently didn't. Over the years I have been at many shows where guitar players have left the stage empty except for howls of guitar feedback, normally after the final encore. In larger venues, when the front of house PA is powered down and the house light go up, it can actually seem almost embarrassingly quiet when the only sound coming from the stage is a feeding back 100W Marshall stack. Punishingly loud in a rehearsal room, yes. But not so impressive in a 3500 seat venue or on an open air festival stage. For me this is a slip of the rock and roll stage mask, where the cool, 'loud' stage amplification is exposed a being relatively quiet in comparison to the resolutely unsexy functionality of contemporary front-of-house sound systems.
-
[11]
While it is theoretically possible to break thin resonant glass with extreme sound pressure levels at appropriately tuned frequencies, in practice the scenario de Whalley describes is extremely unlikely.
-
[12]
I was reminded of this observation when leaving early from a 2011 Judas Priest show in Doncaster, England. They definitely sounded better from the car park too.
-
[13]
Or perhaps both (a) and (b).
High volume in the form of high sound pressure level (SPL) is ingrained in the aesthetics of many forms of popular music, most obviously in rock and its associated sub-genres, but also in many other genres and styles including various forms of dance music, hip hop, reggae and electronic music. The primary site of expression of the notion of loud-as-good is in the performance of music in public spaces or venues (live, recorded or a blend of both). The reproduction of discourses of loud-as-good is woven through popular music culture, from bands in tiny rehearsal studios to the world record for “loudest” band (Deep Purple or The Who, depending on the year of publication of the Guinness Book of Records). Loud-as-good discourse has been satirised in other media: the “mockumentary”, This is Spinal Tap (1984) and Douglas Adams’ The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy, both of which are addressed here. This essay identifies five discourses of loudness as they appear in music journalism, and in fiction. These are: loud-as-good, loud-as-bad; loud-as-good for the audience, but bad for the journalist; loud-as-good for the journalist, but bad for the audience; loud-as-irrational.
- performance / staging
- journalists / critics
- discourses
- cinema / film industry
- press (musical)
- loudness / volume
Publisher keywords: cinema / film industry, discourses, journalists / critics, loudness / volume, performance / staging, press (musical)
Stone Deaf Forever : les discours de la puissance sonore
La puissance sonore fait partie de l’identité de nombreuses musiques populaires, notamment du rock et de ses sous-genres, ainsi que de la dance music, du hip hop, du reggae et des musiques électroniques. C’est d’abord dans les espaces publics ou les salles de concert qu’elle s’exprime positivement, par la performance, qu’il s’agisse de prestations live et/ou de la diffusion d’enregistrements. Les discours laudatifs sur le volume sonore irriguent la culture des musiques populaires, des groupes jouant dans de minuscules studios de répétition au record mondial du groupe le plus « puissant » (Deep Purple ou The Who, selon l’édition du Guinness des records). Ces louanges ont été tournées en dérision par d’autres formes médiatiques, telles que le « documenteur » This is Spinal Tap (1984) ou Le Guide du voyageur galactique de Douglas Adams, que nous analysons ici. Cet article identifie cinq types d’évaluations du volume sonore, tels qu’elles se manifestent dans la presse musicale ou la fiction : la puissance sonore évaluée positivement, négativement, positivement aux oreilles du public mais pas de celles des journalistes et vice-versa, et enfin la puissance sonore jugée irrationnelle.
- discours
- performance / mise en scène
- journalistes / critiques
- cinéma
- presse musicale
- volume sonore
Publisher keywords: cinéma, discours, journalistes / critiques, performance / mise en scène, presse musicale, volume sonore